11 August 2007

It's going to be a painful 12 months' wait for the Olympics

I don't usually put Oriental-List (see link at side) postings here, but this was a response to the forwarding a blog entries by an Australian journalist at the link above,entry for August 7:


>I was expecting lots of people, but nothing prepared me for the endless streets of large tower blocks and huge skyscrapers.


Amongst many things that might have prepared the author of this piece for 'endless streets of large tower blocks and huge skyscrapers' would have been all the many articles published in recent times by other journalists flown in to Beijing or Shanghai for five minutes and that also begin with the same gormless observation: 'Wow! They've got tall buildings in China!'

You only have to think back to earlier this year (or late last?) when the BBC decided to have most of its programmes for a week come from China. It might also be noted that there have been large numbers of articles recently about multi-billion yuan projects by various "starchitects", of which Rem Koolhaas' striking CCTV building is only one (see Herzog and de Meuron's National Stadium, and PTW's National Aquatics Centre, Paul Adreu's National Theatre, etc. Although admittedly these aren't exactly towers they are amongst the most striking, expensive, large-scale and avant-garde pieces of architecture anywhere on the planet, and not exactly well-kept secrets.)

This is a foretaste of what we can expect during the Olympics when sport commentators may well be expected to file other material on China, or fill in longeurs with observations full of the blandest and most inaccurate generalities.

A few years ago, when some U.S. president or other was on a state visit to China there was a competition on the list as to who would be the first to hear a commentator say that the Great Wall could be seen from space. There was no shortage of entries. Perhaps during the Olympics we should have another, with a prize for whoever spots the first observation that Beijing has tall buildings, and perhaps members could suggest other platitudes to listen out for.

But despite a flurry of articles in the recent past about the fact that (surprise!) the Great Wall cannot be seen from space (next: 'Spiders don't in fact come out of the bath plug hole shock!'), based on the Baldock evidence we'd probably be safe in simply repeating the competition from last time. The Great Wall's visibility at astronomical distances is bound to be asserted by some other journalist who also apparently doesn't read.

To be fair it must be said that much of the utterly limp reporting on China is not due simply to the lack of talent of those parachuted in for a quick report, but due to the fact that the prevailing view amongst less well-informed editors overseas is the 'unstoppable China rising' story: that's the one they send reporters to get, and they will brook no other. Amongst all the mild hoo-hah about a recent Time report on the indifference of younger members of Beijing's miniscule middle class to matters political no one mentioned that the content of the story was certainly decided before the dinner conversation that formed much of its content actually took place. This is how much 'investigative' reporting is done even by supposedly respectable periodicals, and I'm sure I'm not alone on this list in having seen my material re-written by editors in London, New York, and even Hong Kong, to reflect their views when those are in opposition to what is actually found on the ground.

My favourite recent example of this was in the television documentary The Tank Man, shown widely in English-speaking markets in which the purpose of the documentary maker was to show that the events of Tian'an Men Square in June 1989 had been forgotten, and in particular that the authorities had been successful in suppressing all knowledge of 'the tank man'--the lone individual with his shopping bags who stood in front of a line of tanks to stop them, thus creating one of the most familiar news images of the 20th century.

In this film four hapless Bei Da (Peking University) students are handed a copy of the image and asked what it says to them. You can see this painful and embarrassing sequence here:

http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/tankman/view/

It's part six, whose text summary says, 'Beida University students don't recognize the photo of the tank man...'

Unfortunately for this thesis, one of the students whispers, ''89', to which another replies, 'Haoxiang shi!' ('It seems like it') while the commentary over the top nevertheless disingenuously states that she's baffled.

Out loud the students demur: 'I really don't know; I'm just guessing,' and ask whether the photo is a piece of artwork especially put together for the interviewer's 'experiment'.

It's not just that the English commentary lies about the content of the conversation, but that the whole situation is journalistically bankrupt. Of course the four students were carefully picked by the film-maker's minders, although we're led to suppose that the crew just wandered onto the campus (of Bei Da!) and sat down a few random students in front of the camera for a chat. Nothing is said about the fact that the minder is sitting somewhere behind the camera (a point later admitted by the film-maker in an interview for a different programme, apparently without the slightest embarrassment), and what Bei Da student is going to risk piping up enthusiastically with, 'Yes, yes, I know!' in front of a vast potential foreign television audience and at the cost of failing to graduate or being kicked out altogether. Their expressed bewilderment is almost pantomimic, except that it clearly seems to say, 'How could you put us on the spot like this?'

Later the hyper-intelligent Robin Munro, co-author of the best book on the events of June 89 (Black Hands of Beijing), is perhaps fist given this false picture of proceedings as he's co-opted into regretting on film that the Bei Da students know nothing of the those events, when surely he knows better.

The commentary says that the film of the 'tank man' was only shown once on China Television, and that no one under 20 in China is likely to have seen it. Anyone who knows students at Beijing universities will know what nonsense that last part is. Or it's wild coincidence that even I know several who've seen the clip more than once on the foreign English-language channels they are allowed in their dorm rooms. A quick search of Youtube using the terms 'tank' and 'Beijing' produces four options to watch the clip on the first page of results alone. Despite blockage of Youtube in China, there is no way that this clip hasn't been downloaded many times and passed around, and it's naive in the extreme to think otherwise.

This is not to deny that there's a largely successful attempt to suppress all public discussion of those events in China, but that's a good enough point in itself without distorting the facts to suit the thesis, which is nearly as shameful. It's obviously not considered a good enough point on which to hang an entire documentary.

The actual politics here and the detailed truth of what happened in the past are beside the point. These remarks are not about politics but about the problem of getting a reliable picture of China even for trivial tourism purposes. If we can't trust the Chinese media to do anything but lie it's not clear that we can take much of our own media seriously either, not because there's a propaganda agenda in the same way (although sometimes, depending on the owner or the desire for advertising income there clearly is one of some sort or other) but simply because many of our journalists are incompetent, and others are looking to tailor information to make it fit their idea of what appeals.

Getting true and accurate information on China from Western media is actually quite tricky, and if the Olympics turn out to be a propaganda success for the Beijing government, it will be as much due to the parroting of received 'wisdom' and utter laziness on the part of journalists, and the pre-disposition for the sunny or shocking by ill-informed editors, as to its own direct efforts.


>Beijing is full of contrasts ...


Good grief! This isn't a piece of reporting, it's a postcard home. Clearly either no one edits this blog, or 'city of contrasts' has somehow been purged so often it's been re-born as some kind of acceptabe neo-cliche.

And here's an example of the Western press doing the government's job for it, of which we can expect to see a lot more over the Olympic period:


The government went on the front foot to fight corruption last week by sacking 1,500 officials from around the country for failing to fulfill their duties appropriately.


If sacking a handful of officials, which happens all the time, was all it took to have an impact on corruption then the administration would be now be as pure enough to be a candidate for beatification.). This is window-dressing and nothing more, given dignity by being repeated uncritically in Western media, no doubt to be re-translated back in to Chinese, circulated in neibu commentaries as an example of Western reporting, and possibly to be commented on in the very same media from which it originated in the first place.

And the same will likely happen with increasing frequency on the subject of Olympic preparations, and by the time hundreds of reporters are there our screens will be almost entirely full of warm fuzzy images of a joy joy luck luck happy happy China, although at least Baldock occasionally hinted at a less fluffy China. Let's hope there's still room for the voices of some of the resident journalists with a few years in place and decent Mandarin who can sneak successfully around reporting restrictions and whose commentary may get beyond mentioning problems with the smog.

Speaking of which, are those million cars (four million according to Baldock) off the road yet? Can anyone tell? Has the haze cleared enough to reveal the (shock!) tall buildings?
submit to reddit

No comments: